Why care about health care?

Matthew Chanoff For obvious reasons, people with waterfront property might care more about global warming than people who live on mountaintops. Likewise, you’d think U.S.-based EMS companies with razor-thin margins might care more about curbing health care costs than industries with profit margins wide enough to absorb this growing expense.

Oddly, that does not seem to be the case. U.S. electronics industry thought leaders who address this problem are the exception, not the rule.

The continued health of the U.S. manufacturing base depends to a great extent on the productivity of American workers. Productivity is a function of input versus output - the cost of workers in wages and benefits versus the value they create. That ratio is heavily impacted by rising health care costs. Reining in these costs through government policy is the key to keeping the productivity of American workers high enough to justify manufacturing domestically.

In its most recent annual study of health care costs, the Kaiser Foundation reported that the average cost of employer-provided family health insurance in the U.S. increased to $12,106 per employee family in 2007. The employee pays about one fourth of the cost and the employer pays the remaining $8,825. To put that number in perspective, it’s enough to pay the fully burdened costs of a semi-skilled worker on an SMT line in China for six months.

According to Kaiser, these insurance costs have risen 78 percent since 2001. This phenomenon is widely remarked on in the automotive industry, where obligations to current and retired workers add nearly $1,500 to the cost of each American-made car.

EMS companies suffer less than automakers from the legacy of large numbers of retired, unionized workers, but in an industry with average after-tax profit margins hovering around 2 percent, an extra $8,825 per employee could make the difference between a production line staying in the U.S. or going overseas, or the difference between winning a contract and making a dime.

Several of the 2008 presidential candidates have now weighed in with health care proposals. The U.S. electronics industry has a major stake in the evolving debate over how to resolve rising health care costs. It is time to pay attention.

Posted by Matt Chanoff, October 5th, 2007